4 min read • Roofing Resources
When considering a new roof for your home in Northern Virginia, you will have to determine whether you want a metal roof or shingles. Both are great code compliant choices in our climate, but there’s a huge difference with regards to cost, life span and we should not overlook the curb appeal. Here is a breakdown of the metal roof vs shingles question in the same way that an experienced estimator would break it down, so you can make an informed decision before you ever contact a contractor.
The Verdict
The bottom line on metal roof vs. shingles.
Asphalt shingles are the best choice if you are looking for the least initial cost and a traditional appearance. Metal is the clear winner when it comes to longevity and life cycle cost. Metal is rapidly closing the gap on homes where the homeowner is in for the long haul, but for most homes in Northern Virginia, the architectural asphalt shingle remains the leading choice due to it being cost-effective, durable and easily resold.
Cost
Cost: Upfront Price vs. Long-Term Value
It’s the price difference that homeowners see first. The average cost of an architectural asphalt shingle roof in Northern Virginia is approximately $400 – $700 per square (100 sq. ft.) and the average cost of a standing-seam metal roof is two to three times that cost per square when installed.
That is the difference of that premium: longevity. A shingle roof may need replacing once (or twice) in the time a single metal roof lasts. To test the numbers for your home, plug them into our roof replacement cost calculator or read our guide about estimating the cost of roof replacement.
- Architectural asphalt shingles are the most affordable to install, most popular shingle type and are easier to repair.
- Standing-seam metal: initial costs are the highest, but lowest costs over the lifetime of the roof.
- 3-tab vs. architectural shingles: 3 tab is the least expensive but the least substantial; architectural is the modern option and worth the slight investment.
Lifespan and Durability in Virginia Weather
Northern Virginia roofs are subjected to much: heat, humidity, ice and, sometimes, a severe storm. The material you choose directly impacts the effectiveness of your roof in dealing with all of it.
How Asphalt Shingles Hold Up
Under good conditions of architectural ventilation and care, quality shingles will last 20-30 years here. They are fairly wind resistant and impact resistant and repairs on damaged areas are not costly. Find out more on our Asphalt Shingles page.
How Metal Roofing Holds Up
A metal roof could endure for 40-70 years, is wind uplift resistant, will not crack or curl due to temperature fluctuations, and will shed snow and ice. In addition, metal is non-combustible and resistant to wind-driven rain. Please check out our metal roofing options.
What Matters Most
Three key priorities: energy efficiency, looks and resale.
Reflective roofs in the summer will help to keep the attic cooler, which can help save on cooling costs in our hot summer months, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. The Metal Roofing Alliance also notes excellent recyclability and resale attractiveness.
Looks matter too. Shingles provide a classic look perfect for HOA-regulated areas, while metal has a clear modern edge. When properly installed, both can enhance resale value. If your community has an architectural review board, check the materials and color policies first: some Northern Virginia HOAs prohibit metal or will have some types of shingles that are not allowed.
The Decision
What is the Right Choice?
Asphalt shingles are the lowest cost up front, recommended for people who will be moving in 15 years or less, and in neighborhoods where shingles are the common roofing choice. If you are staying for a longer period of time, you need maximum durability and value energy savings, then choose metal. In terms of metal roof vs shingles, the best thing you can do is get a site inspection as various factors (decking, ventilation and roof pitch) can affect the performance of either material.
Questions Homeowners Ask
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, for those who are going to be staying at home for an extended period. A metal roof is more expensive but lasts for two shingle roofs, reducing the life cycle costs. In a shorter ownership time frame, architectural shingles typically offer better value.
The price comparison between asphalt shingles and a metal roof in Northern Virginia is about two to three times more for the metal roof. Actual pricing will vary with roof size, slope and type of metal.
Yes. Typically, metal roofs last between 40-70 years and architectural asphalt shingles last around 20-30 years in our climate.
Not with a modern installation. A well installed metal roof is similar to a shingle roof in terms of noise.
Get a Straight Answer for Your Home
Not sure about metal roof vs shingles? The first step to the best decision is to take a look at your actual roof. For more than 40 years, Summit Roofing has been assisting Northern Virginia homeowners in choosing the roof that’s ideal for them.